For ten years I have secretly been telling my cat owners to avoid dry cat food. The reason I never went public
is that the veterinary community has offered little in the way of research, evidence, or opinion to support this viewpoint. Not
wanting to go on record was purely a defensive stand and in my book I have pretty much promulgated the veterinary and pet food industry
party line on this issue. I am hereby retracting those recommendations.
My private recommendations were
originially directed at cat owners with obesity management issues. The commercially recommended, cereal based weight loss diets (Purina
OM and Science Diet R/D and W/D, among others) never worked very well and, frankly, just didn't make sense to me from a nutritional
standpoint. After having some dramatic successes with some really fat cats, I had something of an epiphany. I eventually expanded
my recommendations to also include those cats with diabetes and those with urinary tract illness. I have now decided to make my recommendations
across the board for those cat owners who are willing to go the extra distance. Dry cat food, regardless of any brand stipulation,
is garbage. It is loaded with carbohydrates which are not at all a natural part of a feline diet and which physiologically tax the
cat's digestive and metabolic capacity. They are the kitty equivalent of breakfast cereal or high carbohydrate junk food. Go to
http://www.all-about-cats.com/long-life.htm by
Elizabeth Hodgkins, D.V.M. and read what she has to say about feeding a cat. Also you should visit
www.catnutrition.org for a plethora
of healthy feeding recommendations. Just get your cat off the dry food as soon as you can.
My version of this
diet that I have recommended in the past was to buy all-meat canned cat food and feed that. I feel that commercial pet food is inherently
poor in quality but the dramatic effect of feeding an all canned food diet compared to the results obtained when cats are fed
dry cat food (any brand), which is loaded with high-carbohydrate cereal, can be amazing. If you have a diabetic cat
or a cat with a significant weight problem or with urinary tract pathology, consider an all meat diet. The Foods and Feeding chapter
has been completely overhauled in the latest revision of. Dr. Hodgkins is something of a revolutionary on this subject but has
some admirable credentials to back her up and has become quite vocal in her stand on this issue.
What to do
in feeding your pet? Check out the food recipes in the appendix to my book, or better yet, check out the home pet food book by Donald
R. Strombeck, Home-Prepared Dog & Cat Diets: the Healthful Alternative, available at Amazon.com.
I criticized a Florida veterinarian for selling an unnecessary cat vaccination to my good friends before they crossed to the Bahamas. I was wrong and I sincerely apologize. The veterinarian had more current information than did I. I was unaware that the entry requirement for cats had changed to include a feline leukemia vaccination. However, my ranting and raving over unnecessary vaccinations is now directed at the Bahamian requirements for stipulating canine coronavirus and feline leukemia in their import permit (form IMP/1(A)). Whether ashore or aboard a boat, these requirements are really debatable as, in both cases either the vaccine efficacy or the threat of disease is arguable -- risk of vaccine versus risk of disease.